Title text:
They’re up there with coral islands, lightning, and caterpillars turning into butterflies.
Transcript:
Transcript will show once it’s been added to explainxkcd.com
Source: https://xkcd.com/3135/
Been trying to learn about the tides around here so I can tell what I’m seeing on the water. Imagine my joy when I found a Casio, which I collect, with tide and moon phase indicators!
And that’s when I learned the Gulf Coast is strange, has diurnal tides (twice a day) the watch can’t predict. Took me an hour and a half to figure out it would never function. The moon phase works!
Tides go in, tides go out, you can’t explain that.
Casio can’t!
Everyone was taught the tides look like two giant water bulges going around the earth in line with the moon.
That representation is oversimplified and false.
This is how the tides look like at a global level. It’s messed up.
Ok, that clarifies things so much better for me. Thank you.
You understand it more after that?
I’m more confused, honestly. But that’s hardly surprising.
The pictures they used to teach us the tides as children came to make less sense to me in regards to certain places having higher tides than others. I couldn’t picture how. That animation clarified how tides are ordered by the Moon and made chaotic by the shapes of land. The planetary ocean bulges they taught us as kids stuck with me too long and prevented deeper understanding. It finally clicked for me.
Fair enough.
I just have a hard time translating what what shown in the video to what’s actually happening. Might be a bit too much to take in at once.
Then again, I haven’t cared much about the tides ever, and I only know that the tides are a function of the moon because of Bill Nye, I think.
My HS “education” was pretty bad, honestly.
Look at one spot and see how it repeats. Like the tides between South America and Africa kind of rotates through the Atlantic.
FlatEarthersSayWhat
Imagine being out exploring new islands, not realizing its low tide. You setup camp for the night on an island that’s relatively flat and close to current sea-level. Then while you’re sleeping the tide comes in and washes your whole camp out to sea…
Come to the beach here in Bordeaux (well, on the coast) and see tourists set up their stuff at low ebb but forgetting they have to watch out for the flood.
Arcachon?
Cap Ferret but arcachon with the Pilat Dune works too!
if you are exploring islands you probably have a solid idea of how tides work.
You probably should, but that doesn’t mean you do. It’s not like anyone makes you take a quiz to go wander around outside.
Plenty of people get themselves into trouble all the time exploring places/things they know nothing about.
i lived near the beach for a while and, uh, i have seen tourists do the stupid. i posit they count.
In the Bay of Fundy, Canada we have the highest tides in the world (53 feet high). It’s enough to make some of the tributary rivers flow backward with the rising tide. I’ve seen it my whole life but it still amazes me to see a harbour completely empty of water with boats sitting on the bottom waiting for the tide to come back in.
“Their moon is tidally locked” is an absolutely metal thing to say about a planet.
Tides in the Bay of Fundy, Canada are 16 metres (50 feet).
See, that’s the part that confuses the hell outta me. How can water be higher in one spot than others just due to the Moon’s gravity? Yeah it’s the geography of the area, got it. But still, how?
I think lightning would be crazy to anyone who never experienced a planet with it. Like, “WTF, sometimes your sky does what?”
woah XKCD is still making comics?
